Shark’s Fin & Sichuan Pepper
Copy & paste from a review previously written on 2008-Sep-26:
Review Title: "A delightful & adventerous culinary memoir"
This is one of the relatively few books out there that I can say, without reservation, that I completely enjoyed to the least and last ... even the somewhat whimsical final chapter about the caterpiller.
Others have already reviewed the book in considerable detail, so I'll just add a few short tidbits that stood out for me in particular ...
* I absolutely adore Ms. Dunlop's adventerous spirit. Theodore Roosevelt's famous "man in the arena" speech somes readily to mind.
* I also admire, and heartily agree with, Ms. Dunlop's astute observations regarding certain silly and deeply ingrained western culinary biases ... such as a general dislike or aversion to rubbery textures, bone-in cuts, offal, bitter vegetables, etc. I also share her love for adventerous dining ... and her disapproval of those who conspicuously indulge in endangered species.
* I also deeply appreciate her efforts to not just share her culinary travels, but also her insights, immersive personal experiences, and the socio-political context of her travels ... it greatly helps to humanize the book for the reader. Disappointingly few authors succeed in that vein. Some successful examples (of fully immersive travel memoirs) are Peter Mayle's "A Year in Provence", and Joseph Campbell's "Sake and Satori". Both are highly recommended - the latter in particular, for those who enjoy high-brow reading.
My one minor nit with this book are Ms. Dunlop's recipes ... she does a wonderful job in leading up to the recipes themselves in order to give full weight and background to her personal experience and attachment to each (something too few cookbook authors do in their headnotes). However, the recipes themselves are somewhat imprecise in places ... such as omiting the recommended knife-cuts to use (ironic after having learned so many in her culinary schooling), or neglecting to explain some of the more esoteric or hard to find ingredients to her western readers. I also found myself occasionally pining for some of the photographs her memoir mentioned ... none were included.
Highly recommended !
I look forward to exploring Ms. Dunlop's other published works.
Have you read this book? Click here to rate it!
Fuchia Dunlop - Shark’s Fin & Sichuan Pepper - 9
Here you can post book reviews for the IBDoF. Share your thoughts with the world and tell us what you think of the latest book you've read.
[NOTE: to create a properly linked book review thread here in TCC, please click on the "Review this Book" link from the applicable detailed book view in the IBDoF database - it will automatically generate a linked review here.
[NOTE: to create a properly linked book review thread here in TCC, please click on the "Review this Book" link from the applicable detailed book view in the IBDoF database - it will automatically generate a linked review here.
Moderators: clong, Mr. Titanic
Return to “The Critic's Corner”
Jump to
- Community Message Board
- ↳ The Reading Room
- ↳ IBDoF Reading Group
- ↳ Announcements on Books, Authors & Conventions
- ↳ The Margins
- ↳ The Appendix
- ↳ The Tap Room
- ↳ Ask The Oracle
- ↳ Forum Feedback & Suggestions
- IBDoF Member Services
- ↳ The Critic's Corner
- ↳ Announcements by the Webmaster
- ↳ IBDoF Site & Database Discussion
- Internet Book List
- ↳ IBList General Discussion
- ↳ IBList Book of the Week
- ↳ IBList Announcements
- ↳ IBList Suggestions
- Official Author Discussion Fora (Moderated)
- ↳ Charles Pellegrino
- ↳ David B. Coe
- ↳ Elizabeth Bear
- ↳ Heather Gladney
- ↳ Jack McDevitt
- ↳ John Dalmas
- ↳ L. E. Modesitt
- ↳ Lois McMaster Bujold
- ↳ Sharon Lee and Steve Miller
- Unofficial Author Discussion Fora
- ↳ Edgar Allan Poe
- ↳ Frank Herbert
- ↳ J.K. Rowling
- ↳ J.R.R. Tolkien
- ↳ Jane Lindskold
- ↳ Robert A. Heinlein
- ↳ Robert Jordan
- ↳ Stephen King
- ↳ William Shakespeare
- ↳ Winston Graham
- ↳ The DOLDRUMS
- ↳ Cordwainer Smith
- ↳ David & Leigh Eddings
- ↳ David Gemmell
- ↳ Douglas Adams
- ↳ H.P. Lovecraft
- ↳ Isaac Asimov
- ↳ Orson Scott Card
- ↳ Philip Pullman
- ↳ Robert E. Howard
- ↳ Stephen R. Donaldson
- ↳ Terry Goodkind
- ↳ Terry Pratchett
- ↳ Ursula K. LeGuin
- ↳ {Genre} Dragonflight & Dragonlance
- ↳ {Genre} Distributed Computing
- ↳ {Genre} Westerns
- Miscellaneous Genres
- ↳ Comics: Graphic Fiction & Anime
- ↳ Romance Books
- ↳ Star Trek & Star Wars
- The Amateur's Alcove
- ↳ L. E. Modesitt -> RPG
- ↳ Poetry, Lyrics & Ancient Classics
- ↳ The Quill & Fountain